Thursday, December 31, 2009

P4K in 2K9

Because it killed a few minutes every morning at work, I tracked Pitchfork's reviews for all of 2009. Not as a gotcha!, or with a goal of maliciousness, but to combine my loves of recordkeeping (stupid Masters in Library Science degree) and music. PLEASE NOTE THAT THESE NUMBERS ARE FOR ENTERTAINMENT/NOVELTY PURPOSES ONLY.

THE BEST AND THE WORST: This year's top records that earned an 8.6 or higher, (and where they ended up on the Top 50 list):
  • 01 Merriweather Post Pavilion, Animal Collective (Domino): 9.6 (#1)
  • 02 Bitte Orca, Dirty Projectors (Domino): 9.2 (#2)
  • 03 Album, Girls (True Panther): 9.1 (#10)
  • T-04 Veckatimest, Grizzly Bear (Warp): 9.0 (#6)
  • T-04 Embryonic, Flaming Lips (Warner Bros): 9.0 (#4)
  • T-04 Tarot Sport, Fuck Buttons (ATP): 9.0 (#11)
  • 07 Fall Be Kind EP, Animal Collective (Domino): 8.9 (--)
  • 08 Only Built for Cuban Linx... Pt. II, Raekwon (EMI): 8.8 (#5)
  • 09 xx, The xx (Young Turks): 8.7 (#3)
  • T-10 The Crying Light, Antony & the Johnsons (Secretly Canadian): 8.6 (#16)
  • T-10 jj no 2, jj (Sincerely Yours): 8.6 (#35)
  • T-10 Warm Heart of Africa, The Very Best (Green Owl): 8.6 (#17)
  • T-10 Psychic Chasms, Neon Indian (Lefse): 8.6 (#14)

As for the three albums from the year-end top ten that didn't quite make the 8.6 cut, they are:
  • Two Suns, Bat for Lashes (Astralwerks/Parlophone): 8.5 (#7)
  • Wolfgang Amadeus Phoenix, Phoenix (Glassnote/Loyaute): 8.5 (#8)
  • Fever Ray, Fever Ray (Mute/Rabid): 8.1 (#9)
~~~

The 5 worst-reviewed albums of the year:
  • Mirror Eye, Psychic Ills (The Social Registry) - 1.4
  • The Spirit of Apollo, N.A.S.A. (Anti-) - 1.6
  • War Angel, 50 Cent (self-released) - 1.8
  • I Love You, Amanda Blank (Downtown) - 2.0
  • The Entrance Band, The Entrance Band (Ecstatic Peace) - 2.2
Two various artist compilations also bear mentioning here:
  • Johnny Cash Remixed (Compadre) - 0.2 -- The lowest-reviewed record of the year.
  • Just Like Heaven: A Tribute to the Cure (Manimal Vinyl) - 1.7
~~~


REISSUES: 15 reissues earned a 10.0 this year, in what was a good year for British band reissues -- even beyond the Beatles:
  • Abbey Road, The Beatles
  • After the Gold Rush, Neil Young
  • Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere, Neil Young
  • Histoire de Melody Nelson, Serge Gainsbourg
  • Kid A, Radiohead
  • Magical Mystery Tour, The Beatles
  • OK Computer, Radiohead
  • Paul's Boutique, Beastie Boys
  • Reckoning, R.E.M.
  • Revolver, The Beatles
  • Rubber Soul, The Beatles
  • Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, The Beatles
  • The Beatles (White Album), The Beatles
  • The Bends, Radiohead
  • The Stone Roses, The Stone Roses
~~~

MONTHLY TOTALS: After removing various artist compilations/reissues, here's the average grade given out each month:
  • January (22 reviews): 7.26
  • February (51 reviews): 6.24
  • March (77 reviews): 6.76
  • April (99 reviews): 6.45
  • May (96 reviews): 6.70
  • June (97 reviews): 6.55
  • July (104 reviews): 6.81
  • August (71 reviews): 6.94
  • September (81 reviews): 6.88
  • October (101 reviews): 6.69
  • November (82 reviews): 6.69
  • December (35 reviews): 6.56
  • 2009 (916 reviews): 6.69
~~~

INDIVIDUAL REVIEWERS: Unlike the above number-crunching, this breakdown includes various artist compilations and reissues, so folks who reviewed several strong reissues may have inflated numbers:
  • Adam Moerder (7 reviews): 6.25
  • Adrienne Day (1 review): 6.20
  • Amanda Petrusich (3 reviews): 7.76
  • Amy Granzin (15 reviews): 7.25
  • Andrew Gaerig (26 reviews): 6.90
  • Andy Battaglia (6 reviews): 7.25
  • Bob Stanley (1 review): 7.20
  • Brian Howe (35 reviews): 7.26
  • Chris Dahlen (8 reviews): 7.73
  • Cosmo Lee (19 reviews): 6.86
  • D. Shawn Bosler (1 review): 6.80
  • David Bevan (16 reviews): 7.36
  • David Drake (5 reviews): 7.42
  • David Raposa (12 reviews): 6.20
  • Douglas Wolk (22 reviews): 6.75
  • Eric Harvey (26 reviews): 6.41
  • Grayson Currin (26 reviews): 6.66
  • Ian Cohen (59 reviews): 5.99
  • Jason Crock (25 reviews): 7.07
  • Jayson Greene (21 reviews): 6.85
  • Jess Harvell (47 reviews): 6.31
  • Jessica Suarez (10 reviews): 7.01
  • Joe Colly (28 reviews): 6.65
  • Joe Tangari (55 reviews): 7.48
  • Jonathan Garrett (1 review): 5.50
  • Joshua Klein (45 reviews): 6.41
  • Joshua Love (29 reviews): 6.13
  • Marc Hogan (45 reviews): 6.56
  • Marc Masters (29 reviews): 7.38
  • Mark Pytlik (5 reviews): 7.80
  • Mark Richardson (18 reviews): 8.63
  • Martin Clark (1 review): 8.50
  • Matt LeMay (3 review): 8.50
  • Matthew Murphy (6 reviews): 7.56
  • Matthew Perpetua (29 reviews): 6.41
  • Matthew Solarski (13 reviews): 7.17
  • Mia Clarke (18 reviews): 7.44
  • Mike McGonigal (2 reviews): 7.90
  • Mike Orme (8 reviews): 6.82
  • Mike Powell (23 reviews): 7.05
  • Nate Patrin (49 reviews): 7.30
  • Nitsuh Abebe (2 reviews): 7.80
  • Patrick Sisson (11 reviews): 6.64
  • Paul Thompson (39 reviews): 6.46
  • Philip Sherburne (6 reviews): 7.83
  • Rebecca Raber (25 reviews): 7.01
  • Rob Mitchum (10 reviews): 6.44
  • Roque Strew (9 reviews): 7.10
  • Ryan Dombal (15 reviews): 6.28
  • Scott Plagenhoef (18 reviews): 8.58
  • Sean Fennessey (4 reviews): 6.82
  • Stephen M. Deusner (67 reviews - most reviews): 6.64
  • Stephen Trousse (2 reviews): 5.55
  • Stuart Berman (29 reviews): 7.31
  • Tim Finney (7 reviews): 7.27
  • Tom Breihan (24 reviews): 6.13
  • Tom Ewing (12 reviews): 8.33
  • Zach Kelly (15 reviews): 6.46
~~~
RECORD LABELS OF NOTE: Again, no various artists/reissues included here.
  • 4AD (8 reviews): 7.43
  • Anti- (12 reviews): 6.70
  • Asthmatic Kitty (10 reviews): 6.82
  • Columbia (10 reviews): 6.81
  • Dead Oceans (10 reviews): 6.66
  • DFA (5 reviews): 6.92
  • Domino (14 reviews): 7.22
  • Drag City (17 reviews - most albums reviewed): 7.07
  • Fat Possum (8 reviews): 6.73
  • FatCat (7 reviews): 6.78
  • Guided by Voices, Inc. (5 reviews): 5.90
  • In the Red (8 reviews): 7.41
  • Jagjaguwar (11 reviews): 7.54
  • K Records (9 reviews): 7.20
  • Kranky (10 reviews): 7.19
  • Matador (13 reviews): 7.13
  • Merge (11 reviews): 6.90
  • Mute (9 reviews): 5.97
  • Paw Tracks (5 reviews): 5.78
  • Rough Trade (10 reviews): 6.97
  • Saddle Creek (7 reviews): 5.94
  • Secretly Canadian (10 reviews): 6.37
  • Smalltown Supersound (6 reviews): 7.58
  • Southern Lord (4 reviews): 5.32
  • Stones Throw (6 reviews): 7.45
  • Sub Pop (10 reviews): 7.23
  • Thrill Jockey (10 reviews): 7.08
  • Warner Brothers (9 reviews): 6.53
  • Warp (15 reviews): 6.70
  • Western Vinyl (7 reviews): 7.38
  • Woodsist (8 reviews): 7.57
  • XL (9 reviews): 7.00
  • Yep Roc (4 reviews): 6.77
Pitchfork's Top 50 of 2009

No comments: